In Arizona’s competitive rental market of 2025, deciding whether to allow pets in your properties is more than a gut call—it’s a strategic business decision backed by compelling data. With pet ownership on the rise (over 70% of U.S. households own a pet, according to the American Pet Products Association), landlords face a pivotal choice: embrace pets to attract tenants or restrict them to avoid potential headaches. Let’s break down the numbers, weigh the risks, and explore how to make pet-friendly rentals work for you.
The Upside: Faster Leasing, Longer Stays, and Higher Revenue
The data makes a strong case for allowing pets, especially in pet-loving Arizona. National studies from 2024 show that pet-friendly properties lease 20-30% faster than those with strict no-pet policies. In a state where nearly 60% of renters own pets (per a 2023 Arizona Multifamily Association survey), this speed translates to less vacancy time and more consistent cash flow.
Once leased, pet-friendly rentals foster tenant loyalty. Tenants with pets stay an average of six months longer than those without, according to a 2024 National Apartment Association report. This reduces turnover costs—typically $1,000-$2,500 per unit for cleaning, repairs, and marketing. Longer tenancies also mean fewer vacant units, which is critical in a market where every empty day chips away at your bottom line.
Then there’s the revenue boost. A modest $300 non-refundable pet deposit and a $25 monthly pet fee can generate an additional $500+ per unit annually. For a 10-unit property, that’s $5,000 in extra income without raising base rent. Some landlords opt for higher fees—$50/month or tiered deposits based on pet size or breed—which can push revenue even further.
The Risks: Damage and Liability Concerns
The biggest hesitation for landlords is property damage. Pets can scratch hardwood floors, chew baseboards, or leave lingering odors that require professional cleaning. In extreme cases, unaddressed pet behavior can lead to costly repairs, like replacing carpet ($1,200-$2,000 per unit) or fixing structural damage.
Liability is another concern. Uncontrolled pets could bite other tenants, delivery workers, or maintenance staff, potentially exposing landlords to lawsuits. Arizona’s dog bite laws hold owners (and sometimes property managers) accountable for injuries, making it critical to enforce strict policies.
Mitigating Risks: Smart Policies for Pet-Friendly Rentals
The good news? You can minimize risks with clear, enforceable pet policies. Here’s how Arizona landlords are making it work:
Screen Pets Like Tenants: Require vet records to confirm vaccinations and spay/neuter status. Ask for references from previous landlords to verify the pet’s behavior. This weeds out problem animals early.
Set Clear Limits: Cap pet size (e.g., 50 lbs or less) or restrict breeds with higher risk profiles, like those flagged by insurance providers. Limit the number of pets per unit—two is a common cap.
Charge Appropriate Fees: A $200-$500 non-refundable pet deposit covers potential damage, while a $20-$50 monthly pet fee builds a buffer for ongoing wear and tear. Adjust fees based on pet size or type (e.g., cats vs. dogs).
Enforce Rules: Mandate leashes in common areas, require waste cleanup, and outline consequences for violations (e.g., fines or lease termination). Include a pet addendum in the lease to make expectations crystal clear.
Protect Your Property: Schedule regular inspections to catch issues early. Consider pet-resistant upgrades like durable vinyl flooring ($2-$4/sq ft) or washable wall paint to reduce long-term maintenance costs.
The Arizona Edge: Why Pets Make Sense Here
Arizona’s pet culture is a landlord’s opportunity. Cities like Phoenix and Tucson rank among the top 20 pet-friendly cities in the U.S., per a 2025 WalletHub study. With dog parks, pet-friendly cafes, and a sunny climate ideal for pet owners, Arizona attracts renters who prioritize their furry companions. By catering to this demand, you tap into a loyal, growing tenant base less likely to jump to a competitor’s property.
The Bottom Line
The numbers don’t lie: pet-friendly rentals lease faster, keep tenants longer, and boost revenue through fees. Yes, there are risks, but smart policies and proactive management can mitigate them. In Arizona’s pet-obsessed market, saying yes to pets isn’t just tenant-friendly—it’s a savvy business move. Set firm rules, protect your property, and watch your rentals thrive.
Sources: American Pet Products Association (2024), Arizona Multifamily Association (2023), National Apartment Association (2024), WalletHub (2025).
By Rosenbaum Realty Group - Wednesday, June 4, 2025
Author
